Skip to main content

Three-Dimensional Nature of the new Washington Comprehensive Assessment of Science (WCAS)

The new science assessment does NOT privilege content above practice or crosscutting concepts.

We have heard from two different parts of the region that someone who self-identifies as an NGSS-assessment-item-writer has returned to their district and erroneously reported to supervisors and colleagues that the new NGSS-aligned assessment’s (WCAS) items focus solely on one of the three dimension of NGSS (namely, the Disciplinary Core Ideas, most closely related to our previous notions of “content”). This is idea represents a serious misunderstanding that could derail a district’s transition efforts around NGSS. Not being an item-writer myself, I reached out to OSPI.

Dawn Cope of OSPI’s Science Assessment Team responded with wonder that anyone could come away from item writing with that idea and, explained that all the training materials and the process used reflect the 3-dimensional nature of the NGSS. She shared all the training items for me to examine so I could try and see where the idea came from and I found nothing there that would create such a misconception. Dawn updated the OSPI Science Assessment website last week and included information directed at this misconception [LINK].

I also spoke with Ellen Ebert, our state’s K-12 Director of Science at OSPI. In her opinion, the idea that these assessment items will be 1-dimensional probably reflects the thinking of someone quite new to thinking about 3-dimensional standards; and that it was a mistake to believe that the items will be 1-dimensional. She further explained that a teacher involved in item-writing may work 3 hours on a single test item for submission. But that same teacher doesn’t see the next step in the process: Content Review. So while an individual teacher’s experience may actually have been spent writing 1-dimensional test items, those items would be weeded out through the Content Review process. Ellen also shared her own experience of writing six test items and submitting them, then seeing none of them make it out of Content Review.

Here is a graphic that OSPI uses to show the multi-dimensional nature of the new assessment:


This reminds me of the reality of learning: we know that preconceptions are the lens of perception bias. Human beings have a powerful ability to experience the world not as it is, but through the way we expect that it is. But the WCAS assessment item writing process is engineered to prevent our own confirmation bias from becoming the reality of NGSS-aligned state-level assessment.

Popular posts from this blog

OSPI Bulletin 065-23: Learning Standards Review Update

Summary:  This bulletin provides an update to the information about the learning standards review project addressed by Superintendent Reykdal’s letter to district superintendents dated February 14, 2023. It includes current information about the reviews of the Washington state learning standards for English/Language Arts, mathematics, and science. It also includes a timeline for the review process. Key Audiences:  Educational Service District Superintendents, School District Superintendents, School District Business Managers, School District Curriculum Directors OSPI's Bulletin re: Math, ELA, Science: [ PDF ] Science Updates: [ PDF ]

Mesoamerican Pre-columbian Indigenous Math PD Opportunity in February

Good morning Teaching and Learning Colleagues,   Hope you are staying warm and being safe out there in this beautiful/harsh weather. Team, I am reaching out to ask for your support. Can you all please support the NWESD Migrant Education Program team by spreading our MesoAmerican Pre-Colombian Indigenous Math PD opportunity near and far to all your educator staff/district leader contacts in school districts/buildings who reside in our NWESD 189 region?     This is a rare and unique opportunity for districts and educators in our region. This workshop is also helpful for districts who have in their comprehensive plans to close/reduce math gaps and to increase equity with alternative ways of meeting the unique needs of students in Math.   It is important to note that math teachers Carlos and Sara are coming from Mexico City to bring us MesoAmerican Pre-Columbian Indigenous tools, resources and strategies to support students continue to develop and g...

From The Burke Museum: Professional Development Opportunity for K-12 STEM Teachers

The Discoveries in Geosciences (DIG) Field School  is looking for applicants! The DIG is a professional development and scientific outreach program for K-12 teachers and students operated by University of Washington, Virginia Tech and the Burke Museum. Over four days each summer,  the DIG brings teachers from across the country out to active research sites in Montana or Arizona to participate in fieldwork with leading scientists in paleontology and geology. Teachers in the program have the unique opportunity to participate in authentic research, learn new ways to bring Next Generation Science Standards to their classroom, and can earn continuing education credits.   The DIG Program also provides K–12 educators and their students with free educational resources  available throughout the year. With these resources, students participate in real research...