Skip to main content

Three-Dimensional Nature of the new Washington Comprehensive Assessment of Science (WCAS)

The new science assessment does NOT privilege content above practice or crosscutting concepts.

We have heard from two different parts of the region that someone who self-identifies as an NGSS-assessment-item-writer has returned to their district and erroneously reported to supervisors and colleagues that the new NGSS-aligned assessment’s (WCAS) items focus solely on one of the three dimension of NGSS (namely, the Disciplinary Core Ideas, most closely related to our previous notions of “content”). This is idea represents a serious misunderstanding that could derail a district’s transition efforts around NGSS. Not being an item-writer myself, I reached out to OSPI.

Dawn Cope of OSPI’s Science Assessment Team responded with wonder that anyone could come away from item writing with that idea and, explained that all the training materials and the process used reflect the 3-dimensional nature of the NGSS. She shared all the training items for me to examine so I could try and see where the idea came from and I found nothing there that would create such a misconception. Dawn updated the OSPI Science Assessment website last week and included information directed at this misconception [LINK].

I also spoke with Ellen Ebert, our state’s K-12 Director of Science at OSPI. In her opinion, the idea that these assessment items will be 1-dimensional probably reflects the thinking of someone quite new to thinking about 3-dimensional standards; and that it was a mistake to believe that the items will be 1-dimensional. She further explained that a teacher involved in item-writing may work 3 hours on a single test item for submission. But that same teacher doesn’t see the next step in the process: Content Review. So while an individual teacher’s experience may actually have been spent writing 1-dimensional test items, those items would be weeded out through the Content Review process. Ellen also shared her own experience of writing six test items and submitting them, then seeing none of them make it out of Content Review.

Here is a graphic that OSPI uses to show the multi-dimensional nature of the new assessment:


This reminds me of the reality of learning: we know that preconceptions are the lens of perception bias. Human beings have a powerful ability to experience the world not as it is, but through the way we expect that it is. But the WCAS assessment item writing process is engineered to prevent our own confirmation bias from becoming the reality of NGSS-aligned state-level assessment.

Popular posts from this blog

OSPI Bulletin 065-23: Learning Standards Review Update

Summary:  This bulletin provides an update to the information about the learning standards review project addressed by Superintendent Reykdal’s letter to district superintendents dated February 14, 2023. It includes current information about the reviews of the Washington state learning standards for English/Language Arts, mathematics, and science. It also includes a timeline for the review process. Key Audiences:  Educational Service District Superintendents, School District Superintendents, School District Business Managers, School District Curriculum Directors OSPI's Bulletin re: Math, ELA, Science: [ PDF ] Science Updates: [ PDF ]

EarthGen: Climate Justice League, Assemble!

EarthGen is excited to share t his cohort-based learning opportunity designed for teachers across Washington State to deepen their Climate Justice learning. Climate Justice League, Assemble! When: Feb 15 2024 9AM - 3PM Where: Good Shepherd Center in Seattle Climate Justice League, Assemble!  is an  in-person offering on  February 15th from 9am-3pm at the Good Shepherd Center in Seattle  and will provide teachers opportunities to critically define climate justice education and improve their understanding of Anti-racist and Anti-colonial science teaching. Educators will be invited to participate in online communities of practice following the workshop. A few things to note: While this learning opportunity is designed for folks that have participated in the Climate Justice League, we are excited to have space for new registrants! Teachers will be provided  sub reimbursement  to attend the in-person session, and upon completion of the session will earn...

From WSOS: A chance for students for a $1500 per term scholarship! Applications due June 4!

Dear Educators,  COVID-19 has impacted our communities, schools, and students in ways we have yet to fully comprehend. Accessing financial aid to re-skill for our future economy is critical for many Washingtonians and is possible through WSOS scholarship pathways. We are currently at the mid-point of our Fall 2020 Career and Technical Scholarship (CTS) application cycle.   WSOS has received far fewer applications over last year and are enthusiastic to enroll 225 new CTS Scholars this June. Can we count on you to promote our offering? Below you will find content we hope will help you promote CTS: What : Apply now for the Career and Technical Scholarship provided by the Washington State Opportunity Scholarship program! The Career and Technical Scholarship (CTS) provides Washington state residents with $1,500 per quarter towards an eligible associate degree, certificate or apprenticeship in a trade, STEM or health care field. Funding can be used at an...